Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Success! Now Check Your Email

To complete Subscribe, click the confirmation link in your inbox. If it doesn’t arrive within 3 minutes, check your spam folder.

Ok, Thanks
Fishing boat sails on the ocean at sunset
Photo: Da-shika / Unsplash

A Fudan Professor Pitched Beijing Paying to Fish Your EEZ

A permit-and-fee access idea floated at the Manila Dialogue skips past a daily arithmetic: foreign vessels off Bajo de Masinloc and Kota Island already thin the catch that feeds coastal barangays.

Carmen Villanueva profile image
by Carmen Villanueva

At the Manila Dialogue on the South China Sea on Monday, November 16, Dingli Shen, professor emeritus at Fudan University's Institute of International Studies, floated an idea that lands hard once you sit with it. Speaking in his personal capacity, he proposed that Manila and Beijing negotiate permits and fees so Chinese fishing boats could work parts of the Philippine exclusive economic zone, according to the Manila Times.

It is not government policy, and it should not be mistaken for one. Herman Tiu Laurel, president of the Asian Century Philippines Strategic Studies Institute, told the same paper that Manila cannot decide fishing access without weighing the implications for other countries with overlapping claims and interests in these waters. He also asked whether Beijing would grant Filipino fishermen similar access to waters under its own jurisdiction.

The arithmetic the proposal skips

Strip away the summit language and the pitch asks Filipino fishers to formalize a loss they already live with. Foreign boats work waters that feed coastal towns, and the fish that leaves does not come back.

The 2022-2023 IUU assessment cited by Context.ph estimates the country loses roughly 107,000 metric tons of fish a year to illegal, unreported and unregulated fishing, worth more than P5.3 billion. The GI-TOC IUU Fishing Index put the Philippines 54th of 152 coastal countries, a middling 2.34 on a one-to-five risk scale, according to the Manila Times and DA-BFAR.

That tonnage is not abstract. It is the difference between a barangay buying its own catch cheap and buying someone else's at a markup.

Not generic overfishing

The pressure at Bajo de Masinloc has a specific shape. In late March, after more than 20 Filipino boats were harassed near the shoal, a patrol logged six China Coast Guard vessels, 20 maritime militia ships and one PLA Navy warship, the Manila Times reported.

In July, Chinese coast guard ships fired water cannons at Philippine vessels on a fuel run, per the Daily Tribune, with Beijing claiming it drove off boats violating its sovereignty. By late October, the PCG said a BFAR vessel still had to deliver fuel to 40 to 50 Filipino boats at the shoal while Chinese coast guard, navy and research ships hovered nearby.

PCG Commandant Ronnie Gil Gavan has described China using fishing and research vessels across several areas to stretch Philippine capacity thin, according to the Philippine Star. The two governments trade claims over who has the right to these waters, and the available reporting does not settle the attribution beyond those two positions. Neither account erases the boats in the water.

Enforcement that keeps running short

The gaps are not secret. In February, the PCG and BFAR confirmed that Starlink drops within 12 nautical miles of the shoal, which means the men getting blocked often cannot even stream proof of it, per the Daily Tribune.

Monitoring itself is shaky. BFAR warned in August that a Supreme Court ruling striking down mandatory vessel tracking could leave authorities blind to incursions, AgNavigator reported.

Enforcement does move. In October, a PCG-led operation with the Navy and Marines repelled five foreign boats near Kota Island in Palawan's Kalayaan, the Philippine Star reported, and a community IUU reporting center opened in Puerto Princesa through BFAR and the US Embassy's Fish Right Program. A patrol that drives boats off one day is not a settled coastline. The vessels relocate, and the catch stays thin where the enforcement was not.

Shen's proposal would turn that daily squeeze into a line item, with Beijing paying a fee to do what its coast guard already does for free. The young fisher reading this does not see a permit scheme. He sees a water cannon between him and the fuel, and a food budget that already lost the fish.

Carmen Villanueva profile image
by Carmen Villanueva

Subscribe to New Posts

Fresh Philippine stories straight to your inbox, free, no spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Success! Now Check Your Email

To complete Subscribe, click the confirmation link in your inbox. If it doesn’t arrive within 3 minutes, check your spam folder.

Ok, Thanks

Read More