The Summit Left Manila With 10 Percent Undone, and That Gap Is the Water Cannon Off Zambales
The 49th ASEAN Summit closed without a finished South China Sea code of conduct. The unfinished part is exactly the part a Palawan fisher needs.
The 49th ASEAN Summit wrapped in Manila on November 17 without the one thing the Philippines wanted to deliver as chair: a finished code of conduct for the South China Sea. President Marcos put the draft at 85 to 90 percent done, according to Philstar, with the main remaining work being definitions of terms. The gavel then passed to Singapore.
That last stretch sounds like a formality. It is not. The unfinished part governs whether the code binds anyone, how far it reaches, and what it actually restrains.
What the missing fraction decides
Foreign Secretary Theresa Lazaro said on November 15 that four issues had been outstanding: legal bindingness, geographic scope, the link to the 2002 Declaration on the Conduct of Parties, and the terms of reference. Negotiators later settled the relationship with the 2002 DOC, which left three. Reuters reported the parties had provisionally agreed on roughly 80 percent of the text.
Read those open items and you see the whole game. A code that is not binding is a press release. A code with narrow scope can exclude the exact waters where standoffs happen. UPI's diplomatic sources reported that the remaining disputes center on binding force, limits on Chinese maritime activity, and the role of countries outside the region.
The progress figures themselves do not line up. Lazaro's number sat near 80 percent. ASEAN Secretary-General Kao Kim Hourn also said 80 percent and expects a finish in 2027 under Singapore. Marcos said the major issues are settled, while Lazaro, days earlier, had listed three still open, including binding status. When the people in the room disagree on how close they are, the honest answer is that the hardest decisions are the ones left.
Why the draft does not reach the fisher
Even finished, the code sets rules for conduct at sea and does not settle who owns what, per Manila Bulletin. The 2016 arbitral tribunal said it would not rule on sovereignty over the land features or draw maritime boundaries; it ruled on maritime entitlements and found that China's historic-rights claim inside the nine-dash line had no legal basis under UNCLOS. For the Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia, and Brunei, the talks also touch fishing rights, offshore resource development, and the safety of vessels resupplying their outposts, according to UPI.
Safety of those vessels is not abstract. Scarborough Shoal sits about 124 nautical miles off Zambales, inside the Philippine exclusive economic zone, with China controlling access since 2012, per Manila Times. On July 23 and 24, China Coast Guard ships fired water cannon at Philippine government vessels running a fuel mission to fishers there, Philstar reported. On September 18, China Coast Guard vessel 21585 rammed BFAR's BRP Datu Magat Salamat during a patrol and fuel-subsidy mission near Palawan, according to the Philippine Coast Guard. In October, a Chinese maritime militia vessel and 22 sampans entered territorial waters off Kota Island in Palawan.
None of the public reporting says the draft code would cover coast guard or militia incursions near Philippine features, because scope is one of the unresolved items. Until signing, Marcos said, the parties keep following the 2002 DOC, the same voluntary document that has governed through every one of those incidents.
So the arithmetic for a fisher in Zambales or Palawan has not moved. The talks are years old, the draft is years old, and the standoff this chairmanship was meant to ease arrives the same way it always has: a coast guard hull, a fuel run, a water cannon, and no rule on paper anyone is obliged to obey.