Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Success! Now Check Your Email

To complete Subscribe, click the confirmation link in your inbox. If it doesn’t arrive within 3 minutes, check your spam folder.

Ok, Thanks

Three Days at Camp Bagong Diwa, and the Permit Question Never Got Answered

When the Palace calls a dispersal crowd management, student organizers learn their paperwork and their legal observers weigh less than how the footage gets framed afterward.

Jose Dela Cruz profile image
by Jose Dela Cruz
people in crowded city street
Photo: Michael Buillerey / Unsplash

More than 200 anti-Pax Silica protesters arrested on November 15 in Barangay Sucat, Muntinlupa, were held at Camp Bagong Diwa in Taguig for more than 70 hours before the Muntinlupa City Prosecutor's Office ordered their release in a resolution issued November 18, according to Rappler and the Manila Bulletin. Two of five charges were tossed for lack of evidence, per the Philippine STAR.

Palace Press Officer Claire Castro said President Marcos ordered the PNP to use maximum tolerance, and urged the public to establish the facts before concluding that police abused anyone, per the Philippine News Agency. She added, in Filipino, that protesters are free to act but should not go too far.

That last clause is where the whole thing turns. Someone draws the line between acting and going too far, and over those three days in November it was not the people who came to protest.

The permit question never settled anything

No public source confirms whether the groups arrested in Manila or Muntinlupa held rally permits at all. Muntinlupa police cited Batas Pambansa 880, the public assembly law, to argue that rallies belong in a freedom park or need a local permit. On November 17, police said the rally could continue at the freedom park but could not march toward the PICC, citing summit security, according to the Inquirer.

So the fight was never really about who filed what. It became whether the route touched the summit, and the answer was decided by the people guarding the summit. A legal observer logging badge numbers does not change that calculus when the destination itself is off limits.

Keep the two sites apart, because the official framing blurs them. Police and protesters clashed at Liwasang Bonifacio in Manila on the morning of November 15, where the Manila Bulletin reported about 11 arrests. The more than 200 detained at Camp Bagong Diwa were arrested in Muntinlupa, a separate action. Reading them as one dispersal is exactly how a hundreds-long arrest count gets softened into a bad morning.

The detail that should stick: lawyers and families arrived at Camp Bagong Diwa around 5 p.m. and did not reach the detainees until roughly 10 p.m., Rep. Sarah Elago told GMA News. Five hours of a clock running while the Palace frames the footage.

Who decides where the line sits

Amnesty International called for immediate release and accused the PNP of violating the right to protest, per Newsweek. The Manila Times reported videos online showing police deliberately harming demonstrators. The Palace maintains police did not start the violence. Both versions cannot be the record, and the gap between them is exactly where a young demonstrator has to make a decision the next time a call goes out.

Here is that decision in plain terms. You can show up, with a lawyer on speed dial and a camera rolling, and still spend more than 70 hours in a cell before a prosecutor tosses the weakest charges and forwards the rest for further investigation. The dismissed counts do not refund the three days.

The arrest numbers themselves tell you how loose the accounting is. About 11 at Liwasang Bonifacio per the Manila Bulletin, 209 cited by police in the STAR, 236 released per Rappler, about 300 per organizers. When the count of who was taken shifts by hundreds depending on who you ask, the framing is doing more work than the facts.

Meanwhile a DTI undersecretary told Rappler that Pax Silica will be signed before the year ends. The deal the crowd came to oppose moves forward on schedule. The people who came to oppose it spent the week getting released, charge by charge, and counting the hours.

Jose Dela Cruz profile image
by Jose Dela Cruz

Subscribe to New Posts

Fresh Philippine stories straight to your inbox, free, no spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Success! Now Check Your Email

To complete Subscribe, click the confirmation link in your inbox. If it doesn’t arrive within 3 minutes, check your spam folder.

Ok, Thanks

Read More