Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Success! Now Check Your Email

To complete Subscribe, click the confirmation link in your inbox. If it doesn’t arrive within 3 minutes, check your spam folder.

Ok, Thanks

A Permit They Were Told They Lacked: Three UMak Councilors Booked at the Campus Gate

The rulebook on rally permits reads one way at a BGC campus gate and another at a credentialed ASEAN summit. The paperwork lands hardest on whoever has the least cover.

Jose Dela Cruz profile image
by Jose Dela Cruz
a crowd of people standing around each other
Photo: Reign Berhay / Unsplash

On Nov. 13, police arrested three University of Makati student councilors outside their campus in Bonifacio Global City during a youth mobilization against the Pax Silica initiative. Bulatlat, citing Panday Sining UMak, reported that uniformed police and plainclothes intelligence personnel surrounded the demonstrators, confronted them over an alleged unauthorized assembly, and confiscated their placards. The Daily Tribune, drawing on student eyewitness accounts, reported that police raised the alleged lack of a rally permit. The three were held at BGC Police Station 1 and faced initial charges of alarms and scandal, and the Daily Tribune reported officers punching several demonstrators and putting one student in a chokehold.

Two days later, more than 200 protesters were arrested in Muntinlupa. The PNP said the Lakbayan ng Timog Katagalugan delegates refused police instructions and protested on a public road. The Inquirer and the Philippine Star reported more than 200 protesters detained; NUPL's count of 276 covers protesters and journalists together. Among those detained were five Mangyan and Hanunuo minors aged 14 or younger, later discharged to Bahay Pag-asa, per the Inquirer.

Same rulebook, different enforcement

Strip away the slogans and both cases turn on one question: who gets to occupy public space, and on whose paperwork. A credentialed ASEAN summit runs on a wall of permits, accreditation, and security cordons the state builds for itself. A student mobilization at a campus gate runs on whether the dispersal unit decides to read the assembly as lawful.

The gap is in how the rulebook gets applied. A summit's permissions are presumed valid because the state built the event. A student action's permissions are presumed suspect, and by the time anyone argues otherwise, officers have already called it an unauthorized assembly and taken the placards.

The permit question runs through both cases. In BGC, police raised authorization on the spot before the booking sheet said alarms and scandal. In Muntinlupa, the complaints cite illegal assembly, direct assault, and resistance and disobedience under the Revised Penal Code, according to the Inquirer. An illegal-assembly count keeps the same question alive: who authorized the gathering, and did the state ever intend to let it proceed.

What the arrest costs before any verdict

On Nov. 17, the National Union of Peoples' Lawyers filed a motion with the Muntinlupa City prosecutor seeking the immediate release of the 276 detainees and dismissal of the complaints. NUPL argued they were held past the period the law allows and that most went nearly 24 hours without a lawyer. The NCRPO said on Nov. 18 that the arrested protesters were awaiting court commitment orders.

Awaiting commitment orders means custody, not release. Even when charges thin out, a complaint can grind through a prosecutor's docket for months, and an illegal-assembly count keeps the authorization question open long after everyone has gone home.

For a student councilor, the clock does specific damage. A booking and an arrest record can follow a board exam application, a first job's background check, a visa form. Detention lands on a class schedule that doesn't pause for custody. Bail and lawyer's fees come out of an allowance, not a salary. None of that reverses cleanly if a case is later dropped, and there is no public record that the UMak charges have been.

The Philippine Alliance of Human Rights Advocates demanded the councilors' release and an impartial probe into the police violence, and the UMak College of Governance and Public Policy student council condemned the arrests. Both demands rest on the same fact: the permit regime protects a summit the state wants held and strands students who showed up for one afternoon, charged with assembling without the authorization the officers decided they lacked.

Jose Dela Cruz profile image
by Jose Dela Cruz

Subscribe to New Posts

Fresh Philippine stories straight to your inbox, free, no spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Success! Now Check Your Email

To complete Subscribe, click the confirmation link in your inbox. If it doesn’t arrive within 3 minutes, check your spam folder.

Ok, Thanks

Read More