The Streams Pay Less Than a Studio Hour. Customs Taxes the Vinyl Fix Like a Shipment.
A Ho Chi Minh City bedroom producer pressed vinyl to beat Spotify's payout floor. Then customs classified his imported sleeves and plates as commercial goods.
Spotify pays him fractions of a cent per stream. A studio hour in Ho Chi Minh City costs more than a month of plays from a scene that fits inside one room. So he stopped waiting for the algorithm to pay and pressed vinyl instead.
Vinyl was supposed to be the workaround. You press a short run, sell it to the people who already show up to shows, and the money lands in your hand instead of trickling through a royalty dashboard three months later. A hundred records from a small scene can clear what a hundred thousand streams never will.
The math only works if the plates arrive cheap
The region's pressing capacity sits elsewhere. ResurRec. Boutique Vinyl Lab in Bangkok, described as Southeast Asia's first modern vinyl pressing plant when it opened in October 2019, has taken clients from Vietnam. Indonesia's PHR Pressing opened as the region's second. For a producer in Ho Chi Minh City, the plates and sleeves ship in from abroad, and that is where the plan meets the counter at the port.
Customs does not see a hobbyist ordering supplies for a tiny batch. It sees imported goods with a declared value, and it classifies them as commercial. The duties and import handling get applied to the whole order before a single record exists, let alone sells.
So the cost lands up front, in full, on a run that might never recoup. The pressing that was meant to beat the per-stream floor now carries a tax bill the floor never threatened.
DIY runs get priced like factories
The classification makes no distinction between a label shipping thousands and a producer shipping enough for one scene. The paperwork treats both as importers. One has margins to absorb it. The other is pressing records partly to afford studio time in the first place.
Short runs are the whole point of DIY. You press what you can sell to the faces you know, not what a distributor can move nationally. That smallness is the safety. Customs reads the same smallness as a small commercial shipment and bills accordingly, so the per-unit cost climbs higher the fewer you order.
He could press more to spread the tax thinner. But pressing more means ordering stock for people who do not exist, for a scene that cannot absorb it. The cheapest run per unit is the one he can least afford to make.
Two gates, one artist, no exit
On the streaming side, he is a creator too small to earn. On the import side, he is a business large enough to tax. Both systems look at the same person making records for the same few hundred listeners and reach opposite conclusions, each one costing him money.
The streaming payout keeps him off the platforms as a living. The customs classification keeps him off vinyl as an alternative. What is left is the merch table at a show, cash, and whatever he can press before the next order's duties wipe out the last run's profit. The studio hour still has to be paid, and the record that was supposed to pay for it arrives already in the red.